pilgrims inn deer isle me

Deer Isle, ME   Offered for sale at $1,495,000

Overlooking picturesque Northwest Harbor and tranquil Mill Pond, Pilgrim’s Inn on Deer Isle is the perfect place to experience all the things to do in Downeast Maine. This historic post-and-beam inn welcomes guests with the ambiance of a bygone era. Lovingly restored and meticulously maintained, Pilgrim’s inn is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and the building is one of the oldest in Deer Isle. The inn was built in 1793 by Ignatius Haskell as a private home. He was one of the maritime community’s most influential residents, and his home became known as the Squire Ignatius Haskell House.

Details at a Glance:

built in 1793
15 guest rooms with private baths – 12 are guest rooms, 3 are cottages with small kitchens and all have hardwood floors throughout; bathrooms are a mix of hardwood and tile
two parlors on the main floor of the inn with hardwood floors
sitting area downstairs near the bar with hardwood floors
cozy bar with 12-14 seats, 2 beer taps, soda system, ice maker, low boy/wine bar fridge
dining room with hardwood floors and space for 42 seats
fully equipped commercial kitchen with tile floor, Ansul system hood, 10 burner stove, convection oven, fryolator, gas grill,blast freezer, sous vide, large Hobart mixer, walk-in and low boy refrigeration
owner’s open concept apartment with induction stove, newly renovated bathroom, heat pump and a wonderful view over Mill Pond
1.87 acres on Mill Pond
Tax map 23, lots 55 & 56, 20 Main St., Deer Isle
Warranty Deed, Book 6714 Page 147, Hancock County Registry of Deeds
2020-21 real estate taxes $9,392
beautiful exposed posts and beams
wood siding
various sections of new roofing (metal and shingle)
full inn generator
on demand hot water
oil fueled boiler
mini splits for heat and air in guestrooms and the owner’s quarters
private well/septic

Deer Isle – Stonington offers the outdoor and maritime enthusiast’s a sanctuary. There are activities on the water and in the woods. Deer Isle is a working fishing village and also an artist island community, as galleries dot the island all around. There’s a bit of something for everyone. But best of all, an abundance of unspoiled nature and views all around.

Property Details

  • 15 Guest Rooms
  • 15 Guest Room Baths
  • Has Owner’s Quarters
  • Built in 1793
  • Last Renovated in 2019
  • Building is 12,000 SQFT
  • Lot is 1.87 Acres
  • Photo Gallery
  • Property Website
Financial Details

  • Offered for sale at $1,495,000
  • Occupancy Rate: with signed NDA
  • Terms: financials provided to qualified buyers and signed NDA
Contact Information

This property also appears on these pages: